Your Cart is Currently Empty

Have questions? Click here!

Create Your Own Smiley

Double click on above image to view full picture

Zoom Out
Zoom In

More Views

  • Create Your Own Smiley
Product Details

These cookies are baked fresh & hand iced on the weekday after the order is placed and then wrapped and shipped out the following day-- two days after ordering

Made fresh daily by our devoted bakers, who rise with the sun (that’s the way they roll), to measure, mix, cut and bake batch after batch, our Smiley Sugar Cookies are carefully fashioned to reach their deliciously sweet potential with only the best sugar, flour and butter, plus a touch of elbow grease (not really) and a lot of love.

Once the baking and cooling is done, the artistry has just begun (there’s a certain poetry to baking, you know). With a flourish that never fails to delight, our bakers then brandish their finest decorative demeanor and set about hand icing each cookie with our signature smile … go ahead, take a moment here.

Like masters who never tire of the defining stoke, they deftly apply the famous face to our Sugar Smiley Cookies, which transcends language to express undying love, true friendship, charity, team spirit, congratulations, good will, good taste and a host of other ridiculously lovely sentiments we can’t go into right now because we get all emotional, which flies in the face of the smile we honor — and that whole gushy tear thing tends to mess up the icing, too.

But have no fear. We are pillars of self-control. We have to be.

Then our fresh-baked Smiley Face Cookies are delicately packaged and shipped right to you.

Additional Information
SKU 10079
Additional Production Days 1

Product Reviews

Write a Review

Items 1 to 10 of 27 total

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
Delicious! Review by E

The cookies were extremely fresh. Better (softer) even than ones I've bought in the restaurant.
Most recently sent them for a graduation party - would have liked a darker blue so I could more closely match the school colors.
Have also sent black and gold ones to friends/family who no longer live in Pgh, and regular or special shape ones to people who don't live in Pgh but deserve a smile.
Had wanted to order dinosaur ones within the past year but guess that was a one time only shape.

(Posted on 6/6/10)

A Winner Review by Steeler Dan

Great quality and a nice surprise for a loved one that was truly a hit.

(Posted on 6/4/10)

Will definately purchase again. Review by All Smiles

We purchased cookies for kicking off a program at work. Employees loved them. They are much fresher than what you buy in the restaurant. [...]Couldn't be more pleased.

(Posted on 5/14/10)

I would buy this again and again Review by ad

Cookies were very fresh, came very fast, my kids loved them and loved that they got to create their own.

(Posted on 3/12/10)

would like a rainbow dozen Review by jo

wish you could make assorted colors with create your own cookies in the dozen, not just one base, and face color.

(Posted on 3/6/10)

They just didn't last long enough! Review by Jami

My mother used to buy us cookies like this in the mid 70's where I grew up. For years I have been looking for cookies to match up with those. I have some friends that told me about these, so I tried them. Oh the memories came back, these taste just like those mom used to buy us. These were great, my only problem, they didn't last long enough!

(Posted on 2/23/10)

Smiley Takes a Trip to North Carolina Review by Aunt June

These were for my nephew, who had a craving for Smiley cookies, so I sent him some in his school colors (black and blue). He said he ate 4 of them as soon as he got them and had 2 for breakfast the next day. I'm sure they were gone as soon as he got home from school that day. [...]

(Posted on 2/17/10)

Penn Stae Smiley Cookies Review by cotton

My daughter lives in the washington dc area and misses Eat n Park. I have been sending these cookies for the past 2 years for her birthday. She shares a little of Pittsburgh with her coworkers.

(Posted on 1/28/10)

Super soft and fresh! Review by Cookie fiend

The cookies were fresh and super soft! A little expensive for a dozen cookies, but once in awhile it is a nice treat.

(Posted on 1/26/10)

Cookies were great!!! Review by Linda

As a very young child, my son was taken to a bakery in Dallas, Texas, after visiting his pediatrician. His treat was a gingerbread cookie. When we received some of your cookies at Christmas, his 25 year old face was transfixed by the memory of those cookies from long ago. I was so dismayed to find that they are available only at Christmas!!!

(Posted on 1/25/10)

Write Your Own Review

You're reviewing: Create Your Own Original Smiley - Gourmet Sugar Cookie

    Rate This Product

* Required Fields

Create Your Own Original Smiley - Gourmet Sugar Cookie

The prototype. The icon. The one-and-only Smiley Cookie — a classic American sentiment, revered by young and old, that says happiness, warmth, yes and more — baked fresh in our ovens, sent straight to your door! That rhymes.

This gift includes:

  - Twelve wrapped 4 inch custom color round Original Smiley Cookies

All cookies are baked fresh and are also:

  - Nut Free (peanut and tree nut free)

  - Certified Kosher (OU – Dairy)


These cookies are baked fresh the weekday after the order is placed and then wrapped and shipped out the following weekday (for example if your order is placed on a Monday, they will be baked on Tuesday and wrapped and shipped out on Wednesday).



  • Create Your Own Original Smiley - Gourmet Sugar Cookie