Are you having trouble with our online store or was there a problem with your order? Check out our FAQ for the answers to many common questions and issues. If you need further assistance, please click here to contact our customer service team and we will respond within 24 hours to your inquiry M-F. Cookies made and shipped from Pittsburgh, PA.
Individually Wrapped Cookies
-
Graduation Gift Basket - Two Dozen Graduation Smiley Cookies
$34.99 -
Create Your Own Dozen Graduation Smileys - Graduation Cookies
$18.99 -
10 Pack Of Wrapped Original Smiley Cookies
$12.99 -
One Dozen Wrapped Original Smiley Cookies
$15.99
-
Case of 50 Individually Wrapped Playoff Beard Penguins Cookies
$59.99 -
50 Individually Wrapped Custom Graduation Cookies
$59.99 -
Case of 50 Individually Wrapped Original Smiley Cookies
$59.99 -
100 Individually Wrapped Custom Graduation Cookies
$97.99
-
Playoff Beard Smileys and Black and Gold Travel Mug Basket
$32.99 -
One Dozen Playoff Beard Smiley Cookies - Go Penguins!
$17.99 -
Treasure Chest Full of 40 Wrapped Mini Pirate Cookies
$34.99 -
Baby Shower Gift: New Dozen Baby Boy / Baby Girl Cookies & Bib or One Piece Combo!
$23.99
-
Apples and Original Smileys Gift Basket for Teachers and Smart Cookies!
$34.99 -
One Dozen Fish Shaped Smiley Cookies
$17.99 -
Wrapped Nut Free Valentines Cookies - 40 Heart Shaped Cookies Basket
$35.99 -
Create Your Own Heart Smiley - Gourmet Sugar Cookie
$17.99
-
Create Your Own Original Smiley - Gourmet Sugar Cookie
$15.99 -
Create Your Own Star Smiley - Gourmet Sugar Cookie
$16.99 -
Star Shaped Smiley Cookies - Gourmet Sugar Cookies
$15.99 -
Flower Shaped Smiley Cookies - Gourmet Sugar Cookies
$15.99
-
Create Your Own Flower Smiley - Gourmet Sugar Cookie
$16.99 -
Pirate Smiley Cookies - Black & Gold Sugar Cookies
$16.99 -
Cookie Gift Basket - Original Gourmet Smiley Cookies in Flower Basket
$32.99 -
Dozen Smiles Starlight Combo - Star and Original Gourmet Sugar Cookies
$15.99
-
Create Your Own Mini Smiley - Gourmet Sugar Cookie
$18.99 -
A Dozen Smiles Bouquet Combo - Flower and Original Sugar Cookies
$15.99 -
Dozen Smiles Heart-To-Beat Combo - Heart & Original Sugar Cookies
$16.99 -
Mini Smiley Cookies - 24 Wrapped Sugar Cookies Perfect for Sharing!
$17.99
-
One Dozen Original Smiley Cookies
$15.99 -
Gourmet Cookies for your Sweetheart - 24 Wrapped Mini Heart Shaped Smiley Cookies
$22.99 -
Heart Shaped Cookies for Parties - 80 wrapped heart Smiley cookies
$54.99 -
Flowers and Smiles Gift Box -12 Flowers and 12 Original Smileys
$32.99
-
Wrapped Nut Free Valentines Day Cookies - 160 Cookies To Share
$89.99 -
Patriotic Cookies - 12 USA Cookies & 12 Star Smileys Basket
$34.99 -
Two Dozen Original Smiley Cookies Gift Box
$29.99 -
Thank You Gift Basket - Star and Smiley Gourmet Sugar Cookies
$32.99
-
Apples Smileys and Original Smileys Back To School Gift Box
$32.99 -
Case of 40 Individually Wrapped, Nut Free Mini Smiley Cookies - Perfect for Sharing!
$34.99 -
Pirate Gift Basket - Black and Gold Mug and Pirate Smiley Cookies
$32.99 -
Gift For Pittsburgh Pirates Fan - Dozen Pirates Smileys & Zoltan T Shirt Gift Box
$32.99
-
24 Mini Pirate Smiley Cookies - Perfect for sharing with your mateys!
$18.99 -
One Dozen Baseball Cookies from Smiley Cookie
$16.99 -
12 Eat'n Park Single Serve Cups, Coffee Mug and One Dozen Smiley Cookies Basket
$36.99 -
Case of 50 Individually Wrapped 4 in Heart Smiley Cookies
$59.99
-
NEW - One Dozen Dinosaur Cookies From Smiley Cookie
$17.99 -
Create Your Own T-Shirt Gift Basket
From: $27.99
To: $57.99
-
Stars and Smiles Gift Basket - Star and Original Smiley Gourmet Sugar Cookies
$32.99 -
Thank You Gift Basket - Heart Shaped and Smiley Gourmet Sugar Cookies
$32.99
-
Heart Shaped Cookies for Valentine's Day - One Dozen
$17.99 -
Welcome Baby Girl Smiley Cookies - Pink Gourmet Sugar Cookies
$15.99 -
Welcome Baby Boy Cookies — Baby Blue Gourmet Sugar Cookies
$15.99 -
Black & Gold Original Smiley Cookies - Made With Pittsburgh Pride!
$16.99
-
Smiley Milk Chocolates — Gourmet Sarris Chocolates
$13.99 -
Smiley Dark Chocolates - Gourmet Sarris Dark Chocolates
$13.99 -
Mini Baby Boy Smiley Cookies - 24 Individually Wrapped Baby Blue Cookies
$17.99 -
Mini Baby Girl Smiley Cookies - 24 Wrapped Pink Sugar Cookies
$17.99
-
Baby Boy Gift Basket Mini Cookies & Bib - 48 Wrapped Baby Boy Cookies
$34.99 -
Baby Girl Gift Basket - 48 Wrapped Pink Mini Gourmet Sugar Mini Cookies and Bib
$34.99 -
Birthday Gift Basket - Flower and Original Smiley Gourmet Sugar Cookies
$32.99 -
Birthday Cookie Gift Basket - Heart and Original Smiley Gourmet Sugar Cookies
$32.99
-
Birthday Gift Basket - Star and Original Smiley Gourmet Sugar Cookies
$32.99 -
Smiling Faces Gift Basket - Gourmet Sugar Cookies and Mug
$29.99 -
Congratulations Gift Basket - Star and Original Smiley Gourmet Sugar Cookies
$32.99 -
Flower Cookie Gift Basket - Flower Shaped Gourmet Sugar Cookies
$32.99