Are you having trouble with our online store or was there a problem with your order? Check out our FAQ for the answers to many common questions and issues. If you need further assistance, please click here to contact our customer service team and we will respond within 24 hours to your inquiry M-F. Cookies made and shipped from Pittsburgh, PA.
Individually Wrapped Cookies
-
Create Your Own Dozen Graduation Smileys - Graduation Cookies
$18.99 -
One Dozen Wrapped Original Smiley Cookies
$15.99 -
Penguins Playoff Cookie Gift Pack
$19.99 -
10 Pack Of Wrapped Original Smiley Cookies
$12.99
-
One Dozen Wrapped Baby Boy Bow Tie Smiley Cookies
$18.99 -
One Dozen Wrapped Baby Girl Bow Smiley Cookies
$18.99 -
Heart Shaped Cookies for Valentine's Day - One Dozen
$17.99 -
Pirate Smiley Cookies - Black & Gold Sugar Cookies
$16.99
-
24 Mini Pirate Smiley Cookies - Perfect for sharing with your mateys!
$18.99 -
Dozen Love My Pirate Heart Shaped Smiley Cookies
$16.99 -
One Dozen Black Out Pirate Smiley Cookies
$16.99 -
24 Individually Wrapped Sunglass Mini Smiley Cookies
$19.99
-
NEW - One Dozen Dinosaur Cookies From Smiley Cookie
$17.99 -
Create Your Own Original Smiley - Gourmet Sugar Cookie
$15.99 -
Star Shaped Smiley Cookies - Gourmet Sugar Cookies
$15.99 -
Flower Shaped Smiley Cookies - Gourmet Sugar Cookies
$15.99