Are you having trouble with our online store or was there a problem with your order? Check out our FAQ for the answers to many common questions and issues. If you need further assistance, please click here to contact our customer service team and we will respond within 24 hours to your inquiry M-F. Cookies made and shipped from Pittsburgh, PA.
Individually Wrapped Cookies
-
Case of 50 Plain Uniced Round Cookies For Decorating
$34.99 -
Case of 50 Wrapped Flower Smiley Cookies
$64.99 -
Case of 50 Individually Wrapped Playoff Beard Penguins Cookies
$59.99 -
Create Your Own T-Shirt Gift Basket
From: $27.99
To: $57.99
-
Basketball Combo Pack - Six Original Smileys & Six Basketball Cookies!
$16.99 -
One Dozen Baseball Cookies from Smiley Cookie
$16.99 -
Two Dozen Original Smiley Cookies Gift Box
$29.99 -
Red White and Blue Cookies - Six American Flag & Six Star Smiley Cookies
$18.99
-
Wrapped Nut Free Valentines Day Cookies - 160 Cookies To Share
$89.99 -
Mini Smiley Cookies - 24 Wrapped Sugar Cookies Perfect for Sharing!
$17.99 -
Welcome Baby Boy Cookies — Baby Blue Gourmet Sugar Cookies
$15.99 -
Welcome Baby Girl Smiley Cookies - Pink Gourmet Sugar Cookies
$15.99
-
Case of 160 Individually Wrapped Sparkly Red Mini Heart Cookies
$94.99 -
24 Smiley Bow and Bowtie Heart Cookies
$34.99 -
NEW - 100 Individually Wrapped Uniced Mini Pink Heart Cookies
$27.99 -
NEW - 100 Individually Wrapped Mini Pink Dough Smiling Heart Cookies
$35.99
-
Gourmet Cookies for your Sweetheart - 24 Wrapped Mini Heart Shaped Smiley Cookies
$22.99 -
Basket of 40 Individually Wrapped Sparkly Red Mini Heart Cookies
$38.99 -
Mini Baby Girl Smiley Cookies - 24 Wrapped Pink Sugar Cookies
$17.99 -
Mini Baby Boy Smiley Cookies - 24 Individually Wrapped Baby Blue Cookies
$17.99