Your Cart is Currently Empty

Have questions? You can always call us at 877.860.3999

Original Smiley Cookies

Double click on above image to view full picture

Zoom Out
Zoom In

More Views

  • Original Smiley Cookies
Product Details

The Original Smiley Cookie

Made fresh daily by our devoted bakers, who rise with the sun (that’s the way they roll), to measure, mix, cut and bake batch after batch, our Smiley Sugar Cookies are carefully fashioned to reach their deliciously sweet potential with only the best sugar, flour and butter, plus a touch of elbow grease (not really) and a lot of love.

Once the baking and cooling is done, the artistry has just begun (there’s a certain poetry to baking, you know). With a flourish that never fails to delight, our bakers then brandish their finest decorative demeanor and set about hand icing each cookie with our signature smile … go ahead, take a moment here.

The Famous Smiley Cookie Face

Like masters who never tire of the defining stoke, they deftly apply the famous face to our Sugar Smiley Cookies, which transcends language to express undying love, true friendship, charity, team spirit, congratulations, good will, good taste and a host of other ridiculously lovely sentiments we can’t go into right now because we get all emotional, which flies in the face of the smile we honor — and that whole gushy tear thing tends to mess up the icing, too.

But have no fear. We are pillars of self-control. We have to be.

Then our fresh-baked Smiley Face Cookies are delicately packaged and shipped right to you, in a variety of face colors — red, green and blue - which can even be customized if you got something in mind, just click here to tell us what kind. Its never been easier to order birthday cookies online!

Nutrition Information
Smiley Cookie Nutritional info
Allergen Information

Our cookies are made in a peanut-free and tree-nut free facility. No peanuts, tree nuts, or nuts of any kind ever enter our bakery. We also ensure that our ingredients are not produced in facilities that process nuts.

Our cookies do contain Wheat, Egg, Soy, and Dairy ingredients.

The Orthodox Union supervises our production and certifies that all of our cookie gifts are Kosher Dairy.

Additional Information
SKU 10000
Additional Production Days No

Product Reviews

Write a Review

Items 101 to 110 of 144 total

  1. 1
  2. ...
  3. 9
  4. 10
  5. 11
  6. 12
  7. 13
  8. ...
  9. 15
Delicious Cookies! Review by Cole and Dusty's Mom

The cookies were extremely fresh and were baked perfectly with the right amount of frosting. I usually buy the cookies while visiting Pittsburgh and consider myself a Smiley expert; this dozen of cookies was the best that I have ever eaten!

(Posted on 1/4/10)

Always worth the treat! Review by babsmn

I now live in Naples, Fl and I gave these cookies to the natives here. They were very impressed and wished they had an EatNPark to go to. I will be getting these again.

(Posted on 12/29/09)

happy surprise Review by the Mom

I sent the cookies as a surprise for my daughter who was studying for college finals. She was very pleasantly surprised and happy to share her smiles with classmates.

(Posted on 12/14/09)

Awesome! Review by Mary

I bought the Smiley Cookies so my purchase total would qualify for free shipping (like I need an excuse!!!). They were SO fresh and yummy!! I ordered them on a Sunday and they arrived Wednesday super soft and fresh - fresher than I've gotten them in the restaurants. Very tasty!!! I would definitely order them again!

(Posted on 12/9/09)

Pittsburgh tradition enjoyed in Chicago Review by Tom P

We had a tough week in the office so I ordered some Smiley Cookies. It was a nice Windy City pick me up and everyone enjoyed my favorite Pittsburgh treat.

(Posted on 12/1/09)

Fun pick-me-up Review by Linda

Sent this to my niece who was sick with pneumonia as a little pick-me-up. She loved it. Said the cookies were delicious.

(Posted on 12/1/09)

Big hit-grandson's school birthday party Review by Sarah

I have sent two dozen each for both my grandsons' school birthday parties in Orlando. They were a hit with the kids both times.

(Posted on 11/24/09)

Great treat!!! Review by JE

I send a dozen of these cookies to my son who is at college 5 hours away. He has loved them since he was little, so he really appreciates going to the mailbox and finding this treat. The cookies are always an unexpected surprise. They are always fresh, and I like that you can specialize the colors- I can do his college colors. Very good value for excellent cookies!!!

(Posted on 11/20/09)

Fantastic Gift! Review by Wen

One of my friends recently got in a bad bicycle accident, and we wanted to send him something unique to cheer him up. We received TONS of compliments on this and that it really brought a smile to his face. THANK YOU!

(Posted on 11/3/09)

It's a winner every time. Review by Larry

Sent to a young, aspiring musical comedy performer on opening night in a professional production. Several others in the cast are from the Pittsburgh area and they appreciated the connection.

(Posted on 10/25/09)

Write Your Own Review

You're reviewing: Original Smiley Cookies - Gourmet Sugar Cookies

    Rate This Product

* Required Fields

Original Smiley Cookies - Gourmet Sugar Cookies

The prototype. The icon. The one-and-only Smiley Cookie — a classic American sentiment, revered by young and old, that says happiness, warmth, yes and more — baked fresh in our ovens, sent straight to your door! That rhymes.

  • Original Smiley Cookies - Gourmet Sugar Cookies